The real truth about dieting

June 8th, 2010 · by Josh · Nutrition and Diet
The real truth about dieting

Hi everyone, welcome to the Fitness Redefined blog!

In my first blog post I’ll be letting you into some secrets of the dieting world – you may think twice before trying the latest dieting craze after reading this!

Every week I’ll be sharing some facts about dieting that most people aren’t aware of, here’s the first instalment for you …

Week 1: very low calorie diets slow down your metabolic rate

The first thing that occurs during a severe calorie shortage is a decrease in your metabolic rate.  The lower your calories, the slower your metabolism becomes.  Simply put; when you eat less, your body burns less. When you eat more, your body burns more.

This metabolic slowdown is well documented.  When calories are restricted, your metabolism decreases by at least 20 – 30%.  With severe calorie restriction, some studies have shown that resting metabolism can become depressed by as much as 45%!  That’s the equivalent of having your daily energy expenditure drop from 3000 calories per day to only 1650 calories per day!

This is why, after prolonged low calorie dieting, you can eat very little food and still not lose weight.

So that’s why it’s so hard to shift those last few pounds!  Join me next week for the next instalment …

Week 2: you seek weight loss at the expense of your health

When weight loss is all you care about, it’s easier to ignore the nutritional value of the food you eat.  You may not be giving your body the nutrients it needs.  You may even be eating things that do more harm than good but when weight loss is your priority that’s what influences your decisions.

You could end up doing things like passing up on nuts and avocados because they’re ‘fattening’ but snacking on low calorie biscuits later that evening because you fancy them – after all you’ve been so good all day and they’re allowed on your programme.

This kind of trade-off is typical of people who think entirely about weight.  They count calories and consume diet drinks.  Counting calories has very little to do with enhancing your health.  Since effective weight loss can only be permanently maintained in the presence of good health, this approach is doomed to failure every time.

Next week we will look at how very low calorie diets make you lose muscle and disturb the chemical and hormonal balance of the body.

Week 3: very low calorie diets make you lose muscle

One of the most devastating effects of the low calorie diet is the loss of muscle tissue.  Once the starvation alarm is triggered, your body begins looking for ways to conserve energy.

Muscle is metabolically active tissue.  Getting rid of it is the body’s way of decreasing energy expenditure.  It’s easy for your body to use muscle for energy.  This process is known Gluconeogenesis – converting muscle into glucose.  This includes skeletal muscles, and internal organs, even your heart muscle!

Study after study has shown that very low calorie diets without exercise will always cause 40 – 50% of the weight loss to come from lean tissue.  Many diets, especially those that are low in carbohydrates, cause large losses in water weight.  Between the loss of water, glycogen and muscle, around 75% of the weight you lose on such plans is not fat!

The initial weight loss on most diets is very deceiving, giving you only the illusion of success.  Even with exercise, if a diet is too restrictive, much of the weight loss will still be lean tissue.

Another home truth about dieting is that very low calorie diets disrupt the finely balanced chemical and hormonal systems in the body.  Here are three examples of this:

a) Increased activity of fat-storing enzymes and a decrease in the activity of fat-burning enzymes
The chief fat-storing enzyme is called Lipoprotein Lipase (LPL).  When you drop your calories too low, your body will produce more LPL and less fat-burning enzymes.

b) Decreased output of the thyroid hormone
The thyroid gland is largely responsible for the regulation of your basal metabolic rate (the rate at which you burn calories at rest).  When your body senses a severe reduction in calories, there is a corresponding reduction in the output of active thyroid hormone (T3).  The result is a decrease in your metabolic rate and fewer calories burned.

c) Unstable blood sugar
Unstable blood sugar and insulin levels is a sure-fire route to weight gain and ill health.  Severely restricting calories, is a great way to destabilise your blood sugar levels.

Next week we will look at how low calorie diets effect appetite and cravings.

2 Responses to “The real truth about dieting”

  1. Great advice Josh. Diets never work in the long term. What works is eating ‘consciously’. Forget ‘depriving’ yourself and start to be ‘conscious’ of eating the things you choose to eat. Notice the subtle taste and flavours; really savour your food. When you allow yourself to eat whatever you like, you can enjoy eating anything, and you are much less likely to over eat.
    Your emotions can play a big part in your eating behaviour. Underneath every feeling there is a need for something: discover what you are really needing and you can find a way of getting that need met, without reaching for food. Food will never solve a problem. So the next time you reach for something and you know that you aren’t actually hungry, ask yourself ‘how am I feeling? and ‘what am I needing?’ Julie Mann The Habitfixer

  2. If you want to drop some weight, there’s simply a single option so that you can accomplish that in my very own belief – HULA HOOPING. Clinical analysis is presently getting taken out within the North america in order to prove that typical hooping promotes core muscle, flexibility, posture, cardio conditioning and strengthens back muscle tissue. In addition to these excellent outcomes, it is enjoyable to perform and a fantastic stress reliever! In some other thoughts, hooping is a total body and mind work out, simply no wonder it appears in the list of top ten approaches to get healthy! Running, cycling as well as conventional exercise equipment such as treadmills and stair-climbers load the body in 1, continuous direction. The body quickly will get used to the challenge, goes into auto pilot and uses less energy and less muscles, ultimately reducing the usefulness of the exercise routine. Hooping, nevertheless, is actually unpredictable, irregularly loading the body and making it constantly adjust and create the entire body move in different directions. Subsequently each and every hooping session is a new, challenging work out.

Leave a Reply